Pepperstone vs IC Markets: Which ASIC broker wins in 2026?
Pepperstone is the better overall choice for most Australian forex traders in 2026, with lower commission on an AUD account, no minimum deposit, and single-login access to every platform. IC Markets is a credible alternative with the longer Australian operating history and a true ECN model, but it asks for a USD 200 minimum deposit and a separate account for cTrader. Both are ASIC-regulated, both publish a 0.1 pip average EUR/USD spread on their raw-spread accounts, and both list TradingView. The difference is commission: Pepperstone Razor charges AUD 3.50 per side (AUD 7.00 round-turn), where IC Markets Raw Spread charges AUD 4.50 per side (AUD 9.00 round-turn) on an AUD MetaTrader account. The verdict rests on published pricing and structural differences, not on measurements from funded accounts.
Quick verdict: Which should you choose?
Why Pepperstone is the clear winner:
- No minimum deposit (vs IC Markets' USD 200) - start with any capital level
- Lower commission on an AUD account: AUD 7.00 round-turn on Razor against AUD 9.00 on IC Markets Raw Spread (MetaTrader)
- Single-login access across every platform (IC Markets requires a separate account for cTrader)
- Stronger international regulator footprint: six additional jurisdictions vs IC Markets' two
- Same published 0.1 pip average EUR/USD raw spread, so the commission gap carries through to all-in cost: AUD 8.49 against AUD 10.49 per standard lot
At-a-glance comparison
| Feature | Pepperstone | IC Markets | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| ASIC licence | AFSL 414530 | AFSL 335692 | Tie |
| Headquarters | Melbourne | Sydney | Tie |
| Founded | 2010 | 2007 | IC Markets |
| Minimum deposit | AUD 0 Trading involves risk. | USD 200 | Pepperstone |
| EUR/USD avg (Raw, published) | 0.1 pip | 0.1 pip | Tie |
| Commission (AUD account) | AUD 3.50/side | AUD 4.50/side (MetaTrader) | Pepperstone |
| Platforms | MT4, MT5, cTrader, TradingView | MT4, MT5, cTrader, TradingView | Tie |
| Single-login all platforms | Yes | No (separate accounts) | Pepperstone |
| TradingView integration | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| True ECN transparency | STP/ECN hybrid | True ECN (25+ LPs) | IC Markets |
| PayID support | Yes | Yes | Tie |
Risk warning: Trading CFDs and FX carries significant risk of loss and may not be suitable for all investors. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Pepperstone Group Limited holds AFSL 414530.
Regulation and safety
This is a Melbourne-vs-Sydney matchup that the rest of the AU forex market often forgets: Pepperstone Group Limited at AFSL 414530 (Melbourne, since 2010) versus International Capital Markets Pty Ltd at AFSL 335692 (Sydney, since 2007 - three years older in the local market). IC Markets has the slightly longer continuous AU operating history; Pepperstone has the broader international regulator footprint (six additional jurisdictions vs IC Markets' two). Both run clean ASIC records with no enforcement actions, no client fund breaches, no significant sanctions.
Client protections are identical: segregated trust accounts with Australian Tier-1 banks, negative balance protection for retail accounts, AFCA dispute resolution access. Neither broker has an advantage here.
Spreads and commission: published pricing
I have not measured either broker's spreads on a funded account. The figures in this section are each broker's published pricing.
On their raw-spread accounts, Pepperstone and IC Markets both quote a 0.1 pip average EUR/USD spread. The commission is where they differ. Pepperstone Razor charges AUD 3.50 per side, or AUD 7.00 round-turn per standard lot. IC Markets Raw Spread charges AUD 4.50 per side, or AUD 9.00 round-turn, on an AUD MetaTrader account. On cTrader and TradingView, IC Markets charges USD 3 per USD 100,000 traded per side. With one pip on EUR/USD worth AUD 14.90 at AUD/USD 0.6713, the published all-in cost per standard lot round-turn in November 2026 is AUD 8.49 at Pepperstone and AUD 10.49 at IC Markets, so Pepperstone is AUD 2.00 a lot cheaper. The working is on the broker cost benchmark.
Does either broker have a spread edge by session?
Not one I can put a number on. A published average is taken across liquid hours, and spreads at both brokers widen in the Asian session, at the daily rollover, and around major data releases. IC Markets is Sydney-based and Pepperstone is Melbourne-based, so neither has an obvious claim to local hours on paper.
If you trade Asian hours or AUD pairs, check it yourself. Open a demo account at each, put AUD/USD and EUR/USD side by side during the hours you actually trade, and watch the live spread for a week. That will tell you more than any published average.
Decided? Skip ahead and open the account with our pick.
Open Account with PepperstoneExecution model and what to check yourself
I have not measured fill rates, slippage or latency at either broker on a funded account, so this section covers how the two models differ and how to check execution for yourself.
How do the execution models differ?
IC Markets runs a true ECN model with 25+ liquidity providers. Pepperstone runs an STP/ECN hybrid. On paper that favours IC Markets for traders who care about the purity of the model, such as high-frequency and EA strategies. For a discretionary retail trader, the difference is hard to see without measuring it.
What should I check before trading size?
Three things, all of which you can do with a small funded account at each broker:
- Place the same market order at both in liquid hours and compare each fill price with the quote you clicked.
- Do the same through one scheduled data release and note the spread and the slippage at each.
- If you plan to use cTrader, repeat the check there as well as on MT5, because the platforms route and report fills differently.
Demo fills are not a guide here. Demo servers do not reflect real liquidity, so only live fills tell you how a broker executes.
Platform selection
Both brokers list the same four platforms. The difference is how you get to them.
Platform access comparison
| Platform | Pepperstone | IC Markets |
|---|---|---|
| MetaTrader 4 | Yes | Yes |
| MetaTrader 5 | Yes | Yes |
| cTrader | Yes (same account) | Yes (separate account) |
| TradingView integration | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile apps | Yes | Yes |
| Proprietary web platform | No | No |
Why does single-login matter?
With Pepperstone, you can switch between MT4, MT5, and cTrader using the same login and funded account. With IC Markets, MT4/MT5 uses one account and cTrader uses a separate account with its own deposit and funding flow. If you want to test both platforms or use them for different strategies, Pepperstone's approach is substantially more convenient.
TradingView
Both brokers now list TradingView among their platforms, so it is no longer a point of difference. Pepperstone supports direct trading from TradingView charts under the same login as its other platforms. IC Markets charges USD 3 per USD 100,000 traded per side on TradingView, the same as on cTrader.
Deposits and withdrawals
Both brokers list PayID, BPAY, bank transfers and credit cards; IC Markets also lists Osko, which Pepperstone does not name. IC Markets requires a USD 200 minimum. Pepperstone's account table shows no minimum deposit, though its funding table shows a 10 minimum by PayID, BPAY or card.
I have not timed deposits or withdrawals at either broker on a funded account, so I am not quoting processing times. Check each broker's funding page for current processing windows (Pepperstone does not publish a daily cut-off time), and make one small withdrawal early so you know how the process works before you need it.
Who wins on specific use cases
Day trader active during London/NY
Winner: Pepperstone. Lower commission on an AUD account and no platform-switching friction.
Swing trader active during Asian hours
Pepperstone on published cost. Published average spreads are the same and Pepperstone's commission is AUD 2.00 a lot lower on an AUD account. I have no session-by-session spread figures to split them further, so compare live spreads at both during Sydney hours before choosing.
Algorithmic/EA trader
Lean Pepperstone. IC Markets' true-ECN structure is marginally preferable for HFT strategies. Against that, Pepperstone's commission is AUD 2.00 a lot lower on an AUD account, which adds up quickly for an EA, and its easier platform access matters for multi-EA deployments.
AUD pair-focused trader
Lean Pepperstone. Pepperstone's commission is lower on an AUD account. On spread, nothing published separates them on AUD/USD, AUD/JPY or EUR/AUD. Watch the live spread on those pairs at both brokers during the hours you trade and let that decide.
TradingView-based trader
Pepperstone on convenience. Both list TradingView. Pepperstone keeps it under the same login as MT4, MT5 and cTrader.
Beginner starting with AUD 200
Winner: Pepperstone. It has no minimum deposit, where IC Markets asks for USD 200, which is more than AUD 200. FP Markets also has no minimum on its MT4, MT5 and cTrader accounts. See the Pepperstone vs FP Markets comparison for the alternative head-to-head.
Pepperstone for cost and platform access, IC Markets as the true-ECN alternative
If you can only pick one, pick Pepperstone. The lower commission on an AUD account, single-login platform access, and no minimum deposit make it the stronger default choice for most Australian traders. IC Markets is a legitimate alternative, not a worse broker.
If a true ECN model matters more to you than cost or single-login access, IC Markets is a reasonable pick, at AUD 2.00 more per standard lot on an AUD MetaTrader account.
The ideal setup for many serious traders is accounts at both. Keep your primary capital with whichever broker suits your dominant trading style, and maintain a smaller secondary account at the other for broker-risk diversification and to compare live spreads and fills for yourself.
For the wider Sydney-vs-Melbourne ASIC ECN broker landscape, also see Pepperstone vs FP Markets (cost-and-IRESS angle), IC Markets vs FP Markets (the two Sydney ECN brokers head-to-head), Pepperstone vs Eightcap (the low-minimum TradingView angle), and Plus500 vs Pepperstone (LSE-listed brand-backing vs ECN cost efficiency).
Pepperstone
No minimum deposit. Platform flexibility. TradingView integrated.
Frequently asked questions
Pepperstone is the better overall choice for most Australian forex traders: lower commission on an AUD account (AUD 7.00 against AUD 9.00 round-turn on MetaTrader), no minimum deposit, and every platform under one login. IC Markets suits traders who want a true ECN model and are comfortable with the USD 200 minimum and a separate account for cTrader. Both are ASIC-regulated, publish the same 0.1 pip average EUR/USD raw spread, and list TradingView.
On published spreads, yes. Both quote a 0.1 pip average EUR/USD spread on their raw-spread accounts. The commission is not the same: AUD 3.50 per side at Pepperstone against AUD 4.50 per side on an IC Markets AUD MetaTrader account. I have not compared live spreads between the two on funded accounts, so I am not claiming an edge for either by session or by pair. Spreads at both widen outside liquid hours and around news.
Both are equally safe. Pepperstone holds AFSL 414530; IC Markets holds AFSL 335692. Both have clean ASIC records, segregated client funds with Australian Tier-1 banks, negative balance protection for retail accounts, and AFCA membership.
Pepperstone wins on platform access, not on the platform list. Both list MT4, MT5, cTrader and TradingView. Pepperstone provides all platforms from a single login, while IC Markets requires separate accounts for MetaTrader versus cTrader access.
Pepperstone, on an AUD account. Razor charges AUD 3.50 per side (AUD 7.00 round-turn per standard lot). IC Markets Raw Spread charges AUD 4.50 per side (AUD 9.00 round-turn) on an AUD MetaTrader account. On cTrader and TradingView, IC Markets charges USD 3 per USD 100,000 traded per side.
Yes. Many active Australian traders maintain accounts at both Pepperstone and IC Markets simultaneously as a diversification strategy, splitting capital to avoid single-broker counterparty risk and to access slightly different execution models. Both are ASIC-regulated, both offer raw ECN-style spreads, and the operational overhead of running two accounts is modest if you use the same MT4 or MT5 platform across both.